While union bosses are busy pretending they’re fighting for the “little guy,” and “workers’ rights,” they’re busy raking it in big time.
The average pay of a fat-cat union boss is $60,000 more per year than the average CEO – this while these union-types complain that the CEOs are taking advantage of workers.
In 2016, union leaders earned an average of $252,370 per year, while business leaders only earned $194,350, Bureau of Labor Statistics figures reveal.
Adding in other perks that come with the job, union bosses cap out at $283,678 per year.
PJMedia is reporting that Airline Pilots Association President Timothy Canoll was the highest-paid union leader, taking home a total compensation of $775,829, with benefits added on top of his base salary of $526,292. The union gave Canoll about $250,000 in perks, including $24,000 in allowances and $29,000 in official business expenses including things like meals and entertainment. And there’s the $196,534 in compensation classified as “Other.”
This information didn’t come out of a vacuum. It was intended to rebut the AFL-CIO’s annual Executive Paywatch report, which highlighted the disparity between CEOs and their employees. The gap between S&P 500 CEOs and their rank-and-file members is enormous, with executives taking $13.1 million compared to $37,632 for the average production worker.
Union officials said this was a “CEO-to-worker pay ratio of 347 to 1.” The union also added that “last year, S&P 500 CEOs got a 5.9% raise while working people struggled to make ends meet.”
There are some serious problems to this, though, economics professor Mark J. Perry told PJMedia.
First, the AFL-CIO report is not based on an apples-to-apples comparison. In its 2014 report, the union said the average worker made $16.94 per hour and $35,239 annually in 2013. But the union used the average weekly earnings in 2013 of $677.87 reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) for non-supervisory workers, and simply divided by 40 hours per week.
This is misleading, because the average work week for these employees was only 33.7 hours, so their average hourly wage was actually $20.14. Not only are the AFL-CIO numbers wrong, but the union is comparing total compensation for CEOs working full time to the wages of primarily part-time employees.
Even worse, the AFL-CIO report seemed to suggest that redistributing CEO pay to workers would bring fairness and riches to the less fortunate. Perry pointed out that this is far from reality. Not only does it imply the zero-sum, fixed-pie economic fallacy, but the numbers wouldn’t even work.
The union reported that “in 2014, CEOs of the S&P 500 Index companies received, on average, $13.5 million in total compensation according to the AFL-CIO’s analysis of available data.” The union did not report the exact number of companies and CEOs included in its report, but even assuming that $13.5 million is the average for all S&P 500 CEOs, that entire group would have earned only $6.75 billion in compensation.
If the AFL-CIO could confiscate that entire amount and redistribute $6.75 billion to the current 97,923,000 rank-and-file workers, each worker would only receive a paltry $69 before taxes, or about $1.33 more per week and less than 4 cents per hour. “In other words, complete confiscation and redistribution of CEO pay would make almost no difference for the average rank-and-file worker,” Perry noted.
Finally, even if the AFL-CIO’s analysis is correct, and S&P 500 CEOs do make an average of $13.1 million per year, that merely represents the most successful of chief executives. The average CEO’s pay across America is a still only $194,350, almost $60,000 less than the average annual salary of union bosses.
Looks like, once again, another Leftist talking point has been completely busted.