Walmart And Costco Considering Ditching Self-Checkout Lines Amidst "Backlash"

In response to growing customer dissatisfaction and concerns over increased merchandise losses, retail giants Walmart and Costco are reevaluating the use of self-checkout lines.

The move follows British supermarket chain Booth’s, which has already removed self-checkout machines from all its 28 stores due to issues with speed, reliability, and impersonal customer experiences.

The self-checkout trend, which initially aimed to reduce labor costs, gained popularity in the early 2000s and saw a surge during the pandemic for its ability to minimize close contact.

However, its association with merchandise losses and with consumer dissatisfaction has led to a critical reevaluation.

Key Points:

Customer Dissatisfaction: Customers have voiced their dissatisfaction with self-checkout systems, citing issues such as slow operation, unreliability, and impersonal experiences. Additionally, customers have struggled with accurately identifying fruits and vegetables, leading to errors at self-checkout stations. Age verification for alcohol purchases has also posed challenges, often requiring staff intervention.

Merchandise Losses: Self-checkout systems have been linked to increased merchandise losses, with some attributing the problem to shoplifting. Retailers with self-checkout lanes experience approximately 4% loss, more than twice the industry average. Factors contributing to this issue include products with multiple or non-scannable barcodes and the need for manual entry of codes for items like produce and meat, resulting in accidental errors.

Security Measures: Stores have attempted to curb losses by enhancing security at self-checkout lanes, such as installing weight sensors. However, these measures have often led to more errors and customer frustration, necessitating staff assistance.

Retailers’ Responses: In response to these challenges and customer feedback, some retailers have altered their approach. Walmart removed self-checkout machines in select New Mexico stores, ShopRite discontinued self-checkouts in a Delaware store, and Wegmans abandoned a mobile app for scanning and paying for groceries due to losses. Costco, meanwhile, has increased staffing at self-checkout areas in response to misuse of membership cards and acknowledged that self-checkout systems contributed to increased merchandise shrinkage.

Do you like self check out?

Critique and Customer Experience: Some customers and critics have expressed frustration with the self-checkout experience, describing it as Orwellian and aggravating. They have raised concerns about the cramped and impersonal nature of self-checkout stations, suggesting that the trend may be degrading the overall shopping experience.

In summary, while self-checkout systems were introduced to streamline operations and minimize labor costs, they are facing scrutiny due to customer dissatisfaction and increased merchandise losses. Retailers are reevaluating their use of self-checkout, and some have already made changes in response to these challenges. Critics also highlight concerns about the customer experience and its impact on the shopping process.

Recently Posted